Why is Personalized Cold Email Important for ROI

Why is Personalized Cold Email Important for ROI

King Abidoye


If you've run more than one cold email campaign, you know that cold email personalization significantly impacts response rate. According to a report by Yes Lifecycle Marketing, cold emails with personalized subject lines have 50% greater open rates. However, according to the same report, only 2% of emails incorporate personalization.

Personalization demonstrates to the recipient that the sender has taken the time to research and understand their needs. By tailoring the messaging to the specific needs and interests of the recipient, a more targeted approach is ensured, which builds trust and increases the chances of converting a prospect into a customer.

What is Cold Email Personalization?

Cold email personalization is about crafting personalized emails that show your potential customer that you've done your homework and care about catching their attention. Yes, you read that correctly. Every cold email you send should be personalized.

This can include using the recipient's name, referencing their company or industry, and addressing a specific pain point or need that the recipient may have. Personalized subject lines, which include the recipient's name or other relevant information, can also increase the chances that your email will be opened and read.

You should avoid sending generic emails with a token personalization, like just inserting the recipient's name into a generic email, because it can be easily spotted as a fake personalization.

Also, having a clear call-to-action in the email, such as asking for a meeting or offering a free consultation, can help increase the chances of a response from the recipient. Remember that compliance with laws and regulations on cold email marketing is also essential.

Why You Need to Personalize Your Emails

Personalizing emails can help increase engagement and conversion rates. Personalization allows you to tailor the content of your emails to the specific interests and needs of each recipient. This can make your emails more relevant and engaging, leading to higher open and click-through rates. The primary goal of creating personalized cold emails is to:

Improve email response rate

The likelihood of your prospects reading the email is reduced if you do not try to personalize it. A recipient's likelihood of opening an email increases if they believe it is relevant. Personalization helps you do just that, so it's a must if you want your cold email outreach to work. An email marketer should understand the concepts of cold email and email marketing and be able to determine which strategy is best for their company.

Additionally, you should receive responses from prospects so that you may advance the sales funnel. Prospects will only respond to your emails if they believe you have conducted sufficient research before contacting them. Once they believe you genuinely are interested in them, you may expect a response.

Increase email deliverability

In addition to increased response rates, all personalized emails have a higher rate of deliverability. This is because spam filters prefer variety. When you reuse the same email templates, the spam filter will become suspicious and block your emails from reaching prospects' inboxes. You can avoid this by creating personalized sales emails. Thus, personalization is the answer to the widespread problem of email not reaching the recipient's inbox. 

In cold emailing, both delivery and response rates are crucial. Nureply AI can help you with both. If your emails are not delivered to the intended recipient's mailbox, there is no point in sending them. The entire email campaign is a waste of time when the emails end up in the spam folder.

It's worth noting that it's essential to strike a balance between personalization and privacy. Customers may want to avoid receiving a message with personal information that makes them uncomfortable. It's essential to make sure that you have permission to use the data to personalize your emails and to be transparent about what data you are collecting and how you will use it.

Best Techniques for Creating Personalized Cold Emails

There are various techniques for creating personalized cold emails, including the following:

  1. Referring to the recipient by name

  2. Using a buyer persona

  3. Employing trigger events

  4. Incorporating comments and compliments

  5. Highlighting prospects' interests

  6. Using pictorial view

  7. Integrating existing technology

  8. Leveraging mutual relationship or referral

  9. Using precise pain points

The Problem with Most Cold Emails

The most typical mistake with cold email personalization is sending generic emails with a token of personalization. Your prospect can spot them from afar and could tag you as fake. However, you can change how your prospect perceives your emails if you deal with the following problems - 

Lack of Personalization 

It will likely be deleted or ignored if your cold email does not address the recipient by name or include other personalized details.

Lack of Relevance

If your email is not relevant to the recipient's interests or needs, it is less likely to be read.

Lack of Value

A cold email that does not provide the recipient with any value, such as helpful information or a special offer, is less likely to be read.

Using a generic Cold Email Template

By using a pre-written or generic template, your email loses the touch of personalization, making the email sound uninteresting and generic. Hence it will not stand out, and your prospect may ignore the mail.

Using Unprofessional Tone

An unprofessional, high-pressure, or overly promotional tone can be a turn-off for the recipient. Don’t be too boring. Your emails should sound professional, polite, and respectful.

Poor Timing

Sending a cold email at an inopportune time, such as outside of business hours or when the recipient is on vacation, can decrease your chances. You want to send your emails when your prospect has a high chance of reading them.

No Clear Call to Action

Cold emails that do not include a clear call to action, such as an invitation to schedule a meeting or make a purchase, can leave the recipient uncertain about the next steps.

Failing to Follow Up 

Not following up with a cold email received after the initial message can make it seem like you're not interested in building a relationship. A single follow-up email can raise the response rate from 9% to 13%. Additionally, sending additional follow-up emails triples the response rate.

Not Being Mobile-Friendly

If your email is not optimized for mobile devices, it may be difficult to read on a small screen. Always ensure your emails are mobile-friendly since over 80 percent of prospects use their phone to view emails. 

Neglecting GDPR or Local Laws 

Cold emails sent to individuals or companies in certain countries may be subject to local laws or regulations such as GDPR(General Data Protection Regulation).  Be sure to double-check your emails to avoid legal issues.

Generally, it's essential to research the recipient, craft a well-written and personalized message, and provide value or a clear ask in the email. And always respect data protection laws.

How to Find Your Email Personalization Opportunities

You can find your email personalization opportunities in the following ways: 

  1. Identify segments of your email list that would benefit from personalized messaging. This could include groups of customers who have similar interests or demographics.

  2. Use the data you have about your subscribers to create personalized subject lines and email content. This could include their name, location, or purchase history.

  3. Use cold email AI tools like Nureply to personalize emails based on data about the recipient automatically. These tools include subject line optimization and dynamic content, which can increase the chances that your email will be opened and read.

  4. A/B testing your personalized cold emails can help to determine which strategies and tactics are most effective. Try different approaches, like different subject lines, email content, and calls to action, and compare the results to find the best approach.

  5. Keep track of the metrics of your personalized cold emails, such as open rate, click-through rate, and conversion rate, and use this information to improve your strategy over time.

  6. Use the insights you gain from your tests and trackings to improve your customer segments and ensure you send the most impactful messages to the right people.

  7. Remember that personalized cold emails are most effective in compliance with anti-spam laws and regulations. Always check and use opt-in databases or subscribers that have explicitly agreed to receive emails from your business.

7 Cold Email Personalization Best Practices to Follow

  1. When crafting personalized cold email examples, using the recipient's name in the email subject and body is crucial to create a personalized experience.

  2. Research and mention specific details about the recipient's industry and interest to show you've done your homework.

  3. Create a sense of urgency by highlighting the potential benefits of your product or service and how it can help the recipient's business.

  4. Use a friendly, conversational tone to build a connection with the recipient.

  5. Keep the personalized cold email examples short and to the point, with a clear call to action.

  6. Test and optimize different subject lines, email copy, and personalization tactics to increase your cold email marketing ROI.

  7. Follow up with the recipient to continue the conversation and build a relationship, provide value, be persistent, and be respectful of their time.

Wrap Up

Personalized cold email is a crucial aspect of targeted email marketing, as it allows for tailored messaging that addresses the specific needs and interests of the recipient. This increases email engagement, leading to improved ROI. Personalizing the email, such as using the recipient's name and addressing a specific pain point or need, helps to build customer relationships, as it demonstrates that the sender has taken the time to research the recipient and their needs. 

Additionally, having a clear call-to-action and ensuring the email is mobile-friendly can increase response rates. Overall, personalized cold email is crucial in today's business landscape as it helps to reach potential customers and generate leads effectively.

Send Better Cold Emails
With Power of Advanced AI

Try Nureply for Free

Create Better Cold Emails with 30 free credits · 14 days free trial
One Click Cancel

Sign up to Nureply's Newsletter and get latest tips about cold emailing

We won't send you any spam.
You will only get news about Nureply and detailed insights about cold emailing
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, improve our products, and analyze our traffic.

By clicking "Accept", or continue browsing our site, you consent to our use of cookies. Read Privacy Policy